6 Comments

I’ve been a big fan of yours for quite a while. I hope that you’re doing well and keeps yourself safe.

Expand full comment

This is a new take on ashes to ashes and dust to dust. Why isn’t it not desecration of a human body?!

Expand full comment

Human composting sounds gross, but ashes buried at sea in a solemn ceremony is very fitting for a sailor, if that is what they want. I agree that an urn on a mantle is also gross and morbid. Stay strong

Expand full comment

I agree that it's distasteful, as is cremation. (I think John McArthur had a good teaching on that.) I'm not convinced that it's a hill I'm willing to die on though. (Pun intended!) I understand that in early Europe communities, (largely Christian), the deceased were buried in wooden coffins in small churchyards. The coffins and bodies would "return to dust" naturally, and later generations would be buried on top. This isn't terribly different, although I'm aware that it's rooted in the modern religion of environmentalism....

Expand full comment

It is terribly different. The reduction of the human body to utility is immeasurably distinct from the simple fact that bodies decay in time. Did you follow the link and read the full article?

Expand full comment

Yes; I did read the full article, and have a hard time getting too worked up about the issue myself. Nothing about physical dead bodies is particularly appealing to me. I've buried both my parents, a brother and a brother-in-law in the last few years, and I don't spend a lot of time thinking about them mouldering in their coffins and the concrete vaults required by the cemetery; I think of them in their true Heavenly Home, free at last from the pain and strife of this world.

Expand full comment