17 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
george schadel's avatar

I would like to point out that our right to bear arms does not come from God but from the Constitution. A document which, if examined closely, strays quite far from the Old testament.

Expand full comment
Sarah Cain's avatar

The Founders who wrote it didn't believe themselves to be "creating rights", for they believed in natural law, with man's rights being given by God. Without natural law and the Divine origin of rights, the 9th Amendment makes no sense at all.

Expand full comment
george schadel's avatar

"The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.". How does one know what 'other' rights people have?

Expand full comment
george schadel's avatar

But isn't the ninth amendment simply a blank check for anyone to declare something as a "right"?

Expand full comment